The Roseate, Edinburgh

The staff made the hotel - they were attentive and very helpful.

Travelled over for my partners birthday, arrived off an early flight. Met Alexander at the door, and he couldn't have been more helpful. The hotel stored our bags while we spent the morning around the city. The room was ready ahead of schedule, and we got an upgrade, which was a great suprise and made the whole experience more enjoyable. Breakfast was fabulous. Hotel staff were extremely professional and helpful.

Nothing. Everything was perfect

Beautiful building

Both buildings were imacculate, full of character, breakfast was lovely, good choice, friendly helpful staff. The room was very comfortable, bed very soft which was to our liking.

We had a lovely time at the Roseate. The room was on the small side but not something that bothered us (as 2 friends staying in the same room) as space was properly utilised. Breakfast was delicious and staff were accommodating of my allergies.
Cozy atmosphere and everyone there was great.

Only small note we have is that we were unable to order any drinks (non-alcoholic / alcoholic) around midnight as the front desk agent did not have access to the system.

Beautiful building, great location and very accommodating of our dog. The staff were also delightful. We had a lovely dinner and breakfast was great also.

Nothing, would definitely stay again.

Beautiful historic mansion. Felt like I was in a period movie set.

Nothing

Alexander did an excellent job. Highly professional. Sets a standard. That same level was not achieved by most of the other staff.

I know the hotel from the past under the previous owners. That level is gone. Clearly a hotel as part of a group. The individual touch is gone in terms of maintenance of the building and overall cleanness. The past was so meticoulous and irrespectively what Alexander is doing more than anybody else, he is not empowered and in charge of running a hotel.

Beautiful place, beautiful food, beautiful room, could not be happier.

Beautiful building and grounds. Dining area very luxurious. Staff were amazing and so attentive. Shout out Zoltan and Alexander for such a warm welcome. Offered us a free room upgrade on arrival. Beds comfy big pillows. Shortbread every day, great breakfast options. Very quiet peaceful area.

30ish minute walk from Edinburgh centre/castle
Few items missing off of full Scottish breakfast.
Couldn’t accept upgrade because that “better” room didn’t have a bath :(

Location and quality of building and accommodation

Beautiful room, upgraded to a suite thank you, and helpful, efficient, friendly staff.

The bar closed early as it was very quiet.

The staff make this hotel, they're all as lovely as they are professional.

Small compact room but adequate for 2 nights stay

Separate location (across road) from main hotel so had to go to main hotel for drinks, breakfast etc

The cosy lounge and the level of attentiveness

Our continental and hot option were brough out at the same time, and the plates barely fit on our small table. It would have been much nicer to have the courses staggered, as we felt rushed. By the time we finished our continental dish, our hot breakfast was cold. When I raised this with the waiter, he simply shrugged his shoulders and said that since it's it had already been cooked he couldn't take it back.

Was a relaxing stay with a lovely bar and restaurant fireside. Easy access to airport is a pus with the airport bus right out the door. All the staff was quite lovely and very helpful!

Great location with good quality rooms and excellent service from staff.

The room was fantastic. Old school charm and feelings, but definitely kept up well. The bed was probably the most comfortable we had in our two week trip in four hotels. Concierge staff was great!

Breakfast was good, but lacked of options.

It’s a characterful historic property probably focused on enjoyment of the cuisine. I was only really there for a quick sleep one night. Appreciated the yoga mat!!!

There are two parts to the property and one must cross the road. My room was in the basement which is always a compromise but it was ok.

Excellent staff really helpful, friendly and helpful. Very clean, great location with easy access to public transport, parking available. Superb breakfast.

Our room was very comfortable and a good size but was in the second property accross the road and in an extension downstairs at the back. The noise insulation from the two adjoining rooms bathrooms was nonexistent.
£20 per day charge for parking is excessive.
I would still recommend this property just ask not to be put in the extension in the annex.

Excellent stay - room very comfortable. In House building opposite the main hotel. Parking at the door and a short walk to Murrayfield Stadium and Haymarket. Breakfast was good quality and tasty.

We were on the lower ground floor in the House building so there was limited aspect. Also some noise from the rooms above and next doors bathroom. Didn’t detract from an excellent stay. The waiter on the second morning brought out our museli at the same time as the hot option!

The hotel is available the city style.

Breakfast Service was slowly.

Service location comfort

Nothing exceptional

Great location, helpful staff, nice breakfast.

The first room we were in was quite small and, in my opinion, not worth the price. However, we were upgraded to another room which was extremely nice and spacious. The staff is very attentive, so I cannot fault them for that.

Beautiful building, well equipped rooms with great staff and excellent cuisine.

Due to the unseasonably warm weather the room was quite hot, despite the fan provided, as the window only opened about 15 to 20cm.