The Roseate, Edinburgh

Perfect location. Fantastic staff. Very comfortable hotel.

Would have preferred a larger room but will make sure we organise that next time.

Excellent stay overall, Zoltan was amazing!

Beautiful hotel Brilliant staff Great breakfast

Nothing

Beautiful interior. Wonderfully preserved. The room wasn’t very big but the bed was very comfortable. Breakfast was nice but on the pricier side. Staff was wonderful, especially during our check-in. They offered us hot chocolate, sat us by the fire and sent us a list of restaurant recommendations.

The fire alarm went off on the first night and took some time to be fixed. They mentioned there’d be some sort of compensation but we didn’t end up getting any. Other than that everything else was lovely.

Great location, about 20 minutes walk into Edinburgh city centre. Shops, cafes and restaurants close by. We took the tram from airport to Haymarket and then 5 minutes walk to hotel. Can join river walk into the centre a few minutes from hotel which was lovely. Lovely, friendly staff. Excellent breakfast. Room was great and the bed very comfortable.

The building looked impressive when we arrived and we were greeted by Zoltan who made us feel very welcome. We were seated in the main room where Zoltan checked us in and offered us a welcome drink, before we were shown to our suite which was very spacious and clean with a cosy living area. We had a great night's sleep and decided to have the Scottish breakfast the following morning, although the menu had lots of options! I have already recommended The Roseate to friends and family and look forward to another visit soon

All fantastic

The style of the building , the staff and the quietness there.

No thing

Location was great. Style and Character of main building was extremely appealing. Young Scottish waiter (not sure his name - blonde pony tail) was very friendly and gave great service. Room cleaning staff wete also very professional and friendly.

Restaurant breakfast and dinner were average compared to local restaurants but expensively priced. Water pressure in bathroom was weak and shower didnt stop dripping.

Lovely property staff were very professional and friendly

Our room was very small

Cannot exist better way to finish our 3-week holidays in Scotland. Amazing experience, divine rest, other world attention from the personal.

Staff is utterly delightful - EVERYONE! Always willing to help, informative, and great company.

The location was a little further away from the main activity. Didn't mind taking the bus, once I understood how to get from A to B, but got turned around alot. Didn't feel safe walking around the hotel at night, so going out in the evening meant taking a taxi.

Warm welcome which continued throughout stay

The hotel was amazing it has a nice old fashioned feel to it and the room was beautiful. We didn’t use the bar but from what I seen it was good. It was a short walk to the city centre or there was a bus stop right outside to take you into it. The staff were all friendly and very informative and took their time to stop and chat, I had a good chat with Zoltan who made me and my girlfriend feel very welcomed.

The property is in an ideal location for Murrayfield if you’re watching the rugby and also not too far outside of the main city centre. You can walk or get a bus that stops right outside the front. The building is magnificent and the room was equally stunning. The service is excellent we couldn’t fault anything.

Nothing!

Lovely room, very quiet, cosy and well maintained

Nothing

Good breakfast. Close to Murrayfield

This experience was so great! They had everything ready, including a bed for our dog. Because the restaurant is not dog friendly they served breakfast directly to our room and it was amazing. We are very happy with our stay.

To park your car and bring your dog there are extra costs associated. We were not aware of this.

Location, friendly staff, and very clean.

Love everything, thank you

The best smelling hotel, period. Staff were excellent and made us feel like the most important people in the hotel. Zoltan in particular made our welcome extra special!

Lovely staff! Very easy to get to from the airport (bus stop right at the door!), good food and relaxed atmosphere

Perhaps a tad on the chilly side in the room, and the shower quite snug!

Really friendly staff and would go out of their way to help you. You even saw them going out of their way with other guests to help if they could.

The wife made me walk to Tesco express.🤣🤣🤣

Comfortable and welcoming with good breakfast.

I wish it was half a mile closer to old town.

Layout and position

Very tasteful decor with lots of character, high quality . Staff were all very friendly and helpful and able to assist with any questions

Didn’t realise we had to book breakfast slot as such had to eat much earlier than would have expected

Very nice staff. I enjoyed welcoming tea. Impresive dining area.

I was offered room in other building across the street.. Noise isolation quite poor beetwen the rooms.

Absolutely Lovely staff. Beautiful atmosphere, we really felt quite luxurious being there.

Nice and helpful staff! Good hotel

At the end they ask for 15% optional service fee/tip. Although says it is optional but asking for it directly is making it very pushy.

Had the best welcome we’ve ever had to a hotel with a sit down and a coffee and a chat before being shown to our room.

That it was over the road from the main hotel. Carpet was fraying. Shower wasn’t great. Staff during breakfast had a cold and was snuffling and snorting making me feel quite ill.

Welcomed as soon as we walked through the front gate. Staff were excellent. Excellent facilities. Room was spotless and well equipped. Ideal location.

Nothing

Decor and was clean. Great location.

Small Room

Attentive, kind, helpful reception staff (given that I had some issues with my room). Especially Juliette and Reya. Wonderful restaurant for both breakfast and dinner.

Underwhelming room.

The steam from the bathroom took a long time to clear as there didn't seem to be sufficient ventilation

Comfortable and friendly and helpful. Great music selection in dining room.

All good

Very comfortable guest house within walking distance to restaurants and attractions. Breakfast is very good with a lot of choices. Be aware that not all rooms are situated within the main house. Our room was in the building across the road from the main house, so a short walk for breakfast in the morning. Overall though an enjoyable stay and very quiet rooms.

Fantastic greeting from gentlemen on arrival. Excellent staff throughout Hotel. Breakfast was excellent and the server was great .

At Breakfast main course arrived with the starters which meant by the time you had eaten your Cereal etc your main course was cold. I noticed this happened on other tables which by their expression they weren't to happy.

The decor was lovely and the room well appointed. The staff were helpful, friendly, and professional.

friendly staff, a nice and quite place

sound insulation in rooms is not that good you can hear the tv and people talking in other nearby rooms floor mat is old and has lots of aerosols (flying particles)

Fantastic service and beautiful room!

Everything was great

Tea upon arrival Greeted warmly by Jamie Cocktails at cozy bar Very comfortable room, the Eday room Tasty breakfast

Staff excellent…friendly and welcoming. Room was good value for money

The room in which we stayed was as advertised and good value but was not quite what you would have expected of a luxury five star hotel

The main hotel looked lovely and we had a delicious breakfast. The staff were lovely.

Wasn’t too enamoured with our room which was opposite the main hotel in a basement next to a rather uninviting common-roomesqe communal sitting area.

Very charming, felt like we were at home, very comfortable. Short walk to bus stop and tram. Highly recommend.

There was no air conditioning and to open a window at night for cool air you had to open the whole window which is a safety concern. Someone could’ve easily just crawled into a window. I suggest latches that prevent the windows from opening all the way. Also very little explanation about how to operate wall furnace and floor heating. Major complaint a party was booked by one of our rooms and it was VERY loud. Had to complain about the noise level. Should’ve booked a location that wasn’t next to bedrooms.

It was in a unique older building and I liked the quiet location. We like to walk so it was in walking distance for to city center if y don’t mind a 1 mile walk. Otherwise there are buses right out front. Staff were very welcoming.

Nothing

Room was nice, I can't say excellent because I was staying in the other building that was a little bit disappoint me. Breakfast was nice and the service as well. The bar was very nice and it's a good spot to spend your afternoon.

I didn't have a room in the main building that I was expecting. I had a room with no view. It was clean and pleasant but as my 1st stay in Edinburgh I would have preferred a room with an outside view.

The hotel was beautiful. The staff were attentive and professional. The hotel is quiet and near mass transportation.

N/a

The staff were extremely friendly and helpful. Breakfast was excellent

Bringing my breakfast bill when I wasn’t ready to leave made me feel I had outstayed my welcome

Beautifully furnished property Cozy quiet room Great staff

Nothing . Everything was perfect

Beautiful! Inside and out. Especially loved the restaurant decor and atmosphere. Loved the playlist when we arrived. Jamie was super helpful, as was the girl working at the bar (regrettably didn’t get her name). We’re willing to hold our bags till check in. Had storage for bags unneeded during stay to help with space.

No face washcloths (seems to be common in Europe). Room was TINY. I’d recommend not going with the petite room unless just one person, or a couple traveling very light (carry-ons only).

Stylish, immaculately clean, great location on all transit routes.

Only trouble we had was the water pressure in the shower. Which was not a big deal.

While you have to consider transport to and from the heart of the city, the bus is right outside your door, Ubers are inexpensive and you will feel grateful at the end of the night when you're peacefully tucked into a more comfortable room without outside noise. I thought the buildings were both beautiful – yet the house across the street is far more modern and I preferred it to the main building – and the restaurant and outside bar was picture perfect. Breakfast is a must one of the days as is taking the local walk into town along the river. I wish I had known about it sooner actually!

The food wasn't as good as I would have liked. Staff was accommodating and comped dinner when we didn't eat it. Overall a very good hotel but I expected more. While my room in the more modern building across the street was more comfortable, my parent's room in the main building (in the same "class") was small and lacking for a luxury hotel price.